You are not supposed to love Sargent
Entering my MFA program in New York City in the late 90’s, the cool heart of the post-modern art world, I learned quickly that such a confession would earn a derisive scoff from your professor in his scuffed black boots. Facile. Fashionable. Flatterer. His deft brushwork and elegant elongation were marks of the petite bourgeoisie, the gaudy aspirations of the nouveau riche of the Gilded Age, and the dilettante extravagance of an aristocracy that was losing societies’ acceptance of their blood ordained standing. Sargent was damned by virtue of his pedigree, his financial success and his milieu, when the true artist’s artist should be a member of the proletariat, the Salon de Refusés. (We can overlook the fact that Manet was a member of this same elite class, can’t we?)
Generally, he was loathed for his dazzling technique. You have to understand that in art school, to say someone had good technique was a slander. It indicated that you were some plodding follower who may have learned some competent methods, but had no bonafide genius to shape the new world of material originality.
Sargent was indeed raised as a member of the well-educated, world-traveled and insular universe of the upper class, a white man in a time when that was the only way to enter the field of glitterati. We could throw him out for the sin of association with the pinnacle of Empire. Methinks thou dost protest too much. Tell me, in what era were the successful artists of the times not the darlings and secret coin of the aristocracy of wealth? The hedge fund managers and tech entrepreneurs who buy the work today are not different.
In art school, we learned to keep our mouths shut and leave our Sargent books at home. But, loving Sargent (or even worse, Bougeureau), became a shibboleth. Slyly, in the back of the classroom, students would ask quietly, “Do you like Sargent?” and in this way find some friends with the same damnable preferences.
The lastest show at the Metropolitan Museum, surveying his early success and highlighting Madame X is so crowded it’s hard to enjoy, and major museums have had a steady drumbeat of major Sargent shows. This would have been unthinkable when I went to art school in the 1990s. But tastes, aesthetics and opinions swing like a pendulum, and a generation of Dowton Abbey and Bridgerton enthusiasts are lining up for his maximalist swagger.
Saying an artist just has good technique is like saying a neurosurgeon is just good with knives. Gifted from a young age, he then worked indefatigably. Every hour of diligence compiling a depth of craft and efficiency, light and form, illusion and bravura. Moreover, he had exquisite taste. Portraiture is murderously difficult, and it is the rare portrait that ascends beyond competence to greatness. Sargent made many great paintings.
For all the things I love in Sargent, his sense of friendship and personal relationship with his subjects is the quality I admire the most. We learn in his biography that he did a lot of generous things to help a lot of people. He befriended many of the incredible minds and talents of his day: Monet, Rodin (pictured above), Ellen Terry, Henry James, to name just a few. Every one of those people spoke well of him. He must have been a great friend to know, a man of real heart.
“Sargent and Paris” is on view through August 3, 2025 at the Metropolitan Museum, NYC

Leave a Comment